Voting Down H.R.1501 - Upholding International Law and
the Goldstone Report
by Diane V. McLoughlin, April 22, 2011
To Members of Congress:
I would like to thank you for not co-sponsoring *H.R.1501, which seeks to withhold U.S. dues to the
UN until it retracts the findings of the UN Fact Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict. I urge you to
continue to not support, or vote for, this resolution.
I would share with you that the crimes committed by Israel in 'Operation Cast Lead' were not
incidental. State-employed rabbis distributed leaflets to soldiers that enjoined them to show no mercy.
The IDF, as well as the government of Israel herself, hold to something called the 'Dahiya Doctrine' -
overwhelming violence against civilians in the belief that this in some way provides deterrence from
attack against themselves. This military philosophy is contrary to international law. The Goldstone
Report confirmed that the Dahiya Doctrine was in force during Israel's 2008 attack and demolition of
Thus, it should come as no surprise that the IDF committed atrocities. What does it mean when an
invading force deliberately destroys a fifth of a region's cropland? It's water and sewage treatment
facilities, which is a form of biological warfare? Schools? Food depots? [2a]
Youtube: One shocking scenario detailed by a representative from the International Red Cross
where the IDF impeded access to the dead and wounded. Rescued babies were found starving
beside their dead mothers.
Results of IDF investigations to-date? An IDF soldier punished with seven months' imprisonment - for
stealing a credit card. Three other soldiers who used a nine-year old boy to open bags the soldiers
suspected were booby-trapped, receive three-month suspended sentences. These, out of 490 incidents
reported to the IDF's military prosecutor. [2b]
Americans should be told the real story. The people in Gaza are war refugees who were driven out in
IDF military trucks at the point of guns out of their homes during the massive organized ethnic
cleansing operation of 1948. Sderot used to be called Najd by its rightful Palestinian inhabitants now
languishing in Gaza under illegal Israeli military siege. 1.5 million men, women, children have been
held captive there for years now, while the world debates the definition of deprivation. The children's
growth is stunted. Do we really need to know more?
Israel broke the ceasefire with Hamas in launching the Cast Lead assault, preparing for months during
the ceasefire to betray this confidence-building calm, and we provided the weapons.
The more Hamas reaches out, the more Israel's right-wing elements react with extreme violence. Land
or peace, they choose continued theft of Palestinian land.
Even though South African Judge Richard Goldstone, the chair of the commission, reconsidered his
personal opinion of the reports' findings (solely by virtue of the Israeli military investigational say-so
into its own conduct), the other commission members have noted correctly that:
“There is no justification for any demand or expectation for reconsideration of the report as nothing of
substance has appeared that would in any way change the context, findings or conclusions of that
report with respect to any of the parties to the Gaza conflict. Indeed, there is no UN procedure or
precedent to that effect.”
But what would cause Goldstone, without consultation with the other members of the commission, to
make conciliatory noises in his April 1st, 2011, Washington Post op-ed? The pressure that has been
applied against an honest accounting in the Report has been immense - pressure I feel certain we will
never know to its fullest dimensions. However, we do know that South African Jewish leadership
threatened to ruin, with a public protest, Goldstone's grandson's bar mitzvah if he refused to meet to
discuss (influence?) the report into the Gaza assault. Prominent Jews are on record as calling
Goldstone everything from an anti-Semite (Israeli cabinet ministers), to a 'despicable human being'
So, again, to members of Congress, I thank you and I urge you to continue to uphold the principle that
human rights and international law apply to everyone - including in Israel.
The shrillest howls of protest are heard when it is suggested that peace will flower in Israel-Palestine
when they are brought together in one secular state with equal rights and the vote for both Jewish and
Palestinian inhabitants. I cannot envision anything that would make them more strong and free. I
wish I could find the words to impart to both sides this bright hope.
Diane V. McLoughlin
Comments are welcome
on my blog
*The bill is pending. To write your Member of Congress regarding H.R. 1501, click here. [Text of H.
R. 1501, entitled, 'To withhold United States contributions to the United Nations until the United
Nations formally retracts the final report of the ‘United Nations Fact Finding Mission on the Gaza
Conflict’; April 12th, 2011; http://www.govtrack.us/congress/billtext.xpd?bill=h112-1501 ];
 Article, 'Army rabbi 'gave out hate leaflet to troops'; by Ben Lynfield in Jerusalem; 27/01/09; The
 'Report of the United Nations Fact Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict' - (otherwise referred to
as The Goldstone Report); Sept. 15, 2009; see, for example, pg. 21 of 575 pgs. of the Advance Edited
[2a] ***Noteable: 'Two senior officers - one the commander of the Gaza ground operation, no less -
were reprimanded for failing to follow their own rules of engagement.'
BBC News, 'The 'explosive admission' in Israel's Gaza report'; Paul Wood; Feb. 1, 2010;
[2b] Document, 'Amnesty International's updated assessment of Israeli and Palestinian investigations
into the Gaza conflict'; Mar. 18, 2011; noting Amnesty International's call, that it, '...urges the General
Assembly to call on the UN Security Council to refer the situation in Gaza to the International Criminal
Court (ICC)'; http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/MDE15/018/2011/en/d7e260da-008a-461b-
 Article, 'Goldstone family drawn into row over Gaza report'; Chris McGreal; 30/04/10; The